This or That

[Shurley]

Metatron

Battle of the Redheads: Rowena or Charlie?

 

[Death]

Difficult, Rowena

Human!Cas or TheEnd!Cas?

 

[Shurley]

Eh, tricky...Imma go with End!Cass, if only because that's my favorite S5 episode

Lucifer!Sam or Michael!Dean?

 

[Death]

Lucifer!Sam

Better entrance: Castiel or Death?

 

[Shurley]

Castiel

Better send-off death scene/episode: Crowley or Bobby?

 

[SwanSong]

Bobby

Souless Sam or Demon Dean?

 

[Bela Talbot]

Demon Dean

Lucifer or Nick?

 

[Death]

That's hard I'm loving Nick this season, but Lucifer

Jack or Mary?

 

[SwanSong]

Jack

Ben or Adam?

 

[Shurley]

Adam, but I don't really care about either of them.

Shapeshifter: Skin or Nighshifter?

 

[Death]

Nightshifter - laser eyes!

Reapers: Tessa or Jessica?

 

[SwanSong]

Tessa

Tessa or Billie?

 

[Shurley]

Billie

Ruby 2 or Meg 1?

 

[SwanSong]

Ohh tough one Ruby 2 grew on me.

season 4 or season 11?

 

[Shurley]

11! It's my favorite season!!!

Season 6 or Season 12?

 

[SwanSong]

Season 12

Original Bobby or Apocalypse world Bobby?

 

[Shurley]

Original!Bobby, though I'm just happy to have Jim Beaver back on my screen

Apocalypse!Castiel or Empty!Castiel?

 

[SwanSong]

They're both terrible! But I'll choose Empty!Castiel.


The bunker or life on the road?

 

[Shurley]

Both. Either. Not choosing

The Roadhouse or Rufus' cabin?

 

[SwanSong]

Roadhouse

Scene -
Boot beer or social spirits (the boys drinking behind the impala or the boys drinking around a table)